The rejection letter says: "Your story, on the surface, appears to be well-told and has appealing characters. However, the writing is episodic; the story lacks direction."
You frown. Huh? The story lacks direction? How could it? Your main character is on a quest; how much more of a direction could you have than that?
Clearly, this editor doesn't know what she's talking about. Oh well. It takes all types... you bundle up your manuscript and send it out to the next publisher.
Six rejections later, you feel more than a bit miffed. This is a good story; everyone in your writing group says so. Your writing style is smooth and accomplished (even a few editors have said that).
So why the heck do they keep rejecting it? It's something to do with the plot; that much is clear. But what?
If you're lucky enough to get feedback, look for clues in the comments that have been made. The moment you see the word 'episodic', that is the biggest and best clue you could have. Not all editors will use this term. They might say things like 'what is the story question?' or 'the character has no clear-cut goal' or 'there is no character growth'. All of these things can point to your story being episodic.
1. What Does "Episodic" Mean?
If someone tells you that your story is 'episodic', they mean that your story is a series of episodes, or events, that are very loosely tied together. The "events" crop up one after the other as a way of entertaining the reader, but there is little character growth between one episode and the next. Nor can we easily see how one event grows out of the one before.
Some examples of how a story may be episodic:
(a) The "Little Tommy had never had such an exciting day!" theme: FIRST: A child starts out in a normal/boring situation. Then something happens to change things. (A child might find a doorway into a magic kingdom, go on a balloon ride, go to stay on the grandparents' farm etc etc)
SECOND: The child sees a series of amazing sights/takes part in various fun activities/experiences several hair-raising incidents.
THIRD: The child says "What a lovely day I've had. I'll keep this fairy land a secret, but I'll keep going back to have more fun with my new friends!" (Or: "Phew. I'm glad that's over. I'm so happy to be back home!") What's wrong with this? There is no plot. Just a bunch of 'stuff' that happens to fill in time.
(b) The "Fantasy Trap" FIRST: The main character is drawn into a different world or discovers that he/she is 'the chosen one'.
SECOND: This character is presented with a 'quest' to prove his worthiness to take up the mantle of the Chosen One. (He might have to free a character/being from enchantment or imprisonment, OR to learn to use the magic that is buried deep within, OR to right a great wrong etc etc.)
THIRD: The character sets off on his quest. On the way he is faced with one challenge after another (Menacing Fantasy Creature #1, the Hypnotic Field of Flowers, the Dreadful Sucking Swamp, the Shape-Changer, Menacing Fantasy Creature #2, the Dark and Deadly Forest, the Awful Abyss, the Mountain of Sorrows, Menacing Fantasy Creature #3 and so on and so on...)
FOURTH: The character overcomes each obstacle in turn. He finally frees the imprisoned Queen or finds the Sword of Destiny or whatever. He saves the land from annihilation or closes the door between two worlds and keeps evil at bay for another 1000 years. Yawn. Another cliched fantasy novel ends.
Now, before you indignantly start to point out the many classic (and popular) fantasy novels that fit into the above formula, let me point out why some books work and some don't (even though they appear to have the same 'ingredients'). This applies to any genre.
1. The character is reactive rather than proactive.
In other words, he spends the book stumbling from one obstacle to another, reacting to whatever crops up. He doesn't sit down and formulate a clear plan of action. Quite often, other characters guide the outcome.
2. There is no story question.
The 'story question' is the question that is aroused in the reader's mind at the beginning of the story: "Will the guy get the girl?"; "Will Mary succeed in taking over the firm?"; "Will Xanor take his rightful place as Head of the Galaxy Alien Committee?"; "Will Laura track down the serial killer before she becomes the next victim?"; "How will Toby find his way back from the Land of Giants?" and so on.
You can see why 'Little Tommy's Exciting Day' type of story doesn't succeed. Tommy doesn't set out to do anything or solve a problem (other than being bored) and is faced with no challenges along the way. Stuff just happens.
Any book needs to answer the story question, but it must be more than a simple yes or no. It must show HOW the main character achieved his goal, and it must show how the character grows and changes as he pursues his goal. He needs to have a plan of action. Inevitably, he will need to adapt to circumstances - but with each new obstacle, the main character must (1) react; (2) evaluate the plan and make necessary changes, THEN (3) move forward. In most episodic stories, the character simply reacts then moves forward to the next obstacle WITHOUT making further plans. Quite often, older/wiser/stronger secondary characters will decide on the next step for him. Not a good idea! This gives you a weak main character.
3. The reactive character does not operate from his strengths.
He magically finds new skills when needed, rather than possessing them beforehand. He overcomes each obstacle by luck, intervention by someone else, or an amazing new talent that comes as a surprise to him.
2. What You Can Do to Save An Episodic Story
Grit your teeth and get to work. After you've diagnosed an episodic plot, then operated on it, you're going to be a much better writer.
(c) copyright Marg McAlister
Marg McAlister has published magazine articles, short stories, books for children, ezines, promotional material, sales letters and web content. She has written 5 distance education courses on writing, and her online help for writers is popular all over the world. Sign up for her regular writers' tipsheet at http://www.writing4success.com/
Long ago, movie directors mastered the technique of creating a... Read More
By far, I have found that the lack of discipline... Read More
Started a book and then got bogged down? Like many... Read More
It was reported that the great American author Sinclair Lewis... Read More
Every writer knows that the urge to write is not... Read More
A book coaching client recently emailed me that she was... Read More
If you are an aspiring writer, or you simply want... Read More
No user manual? Surely you jest!It may seem comical, but... Read More
Picture this scene.Your hero is sitting in a bar. He's... Read More
If you're a writer, you're in business. It doesn't matter... Read More
ACCEPT, EXCEPT Not commonly seen even from unpublished writers, who... Read More
The big question. Do you submit directly to the publishers,... Read More
Hundreds of writing contests tempt screenwriters with the lure of... Read More
Has the thought run across you mind that you might... Read More
First drafts are for getting down the ideas. Anna Jacobs... Read More
A well-punctuated approach letter may make the difference between acceptance... Read More
Writing is a muscle that needs exercise to stay in... Read More
Writers often get stuck because they make assumptions about writing,... Read More
I owe the completion and success of my book to... Read More
What Makes a Great Headline?Headlines are far more important than... Read More
One of the biggest problems that inexperienced writers have is... Read More
In order to be successful with a newsletter, specialize in... Read More
Creative Writing Tips ?I have said above that if a... Read More
As many authors are fond of stating, "Ideas are all... Read More
In large publishing houses, many manuscripts penned by first-time authors,... Read More
In the current job market, many editorial workers have turned... Read More
Iā??ve spoken to hundreds of editors, employers, and project managers... Read More
One obvious question that can get overlooked in the process... Read More
Whenever you sit down to plot a story (or even... Read More
Compiling a list of the history's ten best writers is... Read More
Writers are an insecure lot.It's easy to understand why. You... Read More
How long should your chapters be?I can't resist... I have... Read More
Anyone who has read any of my articles on the... Read More
As a freelance writer, it is important to present yourself... Read More
Think you can't write a book that will sell? You... Read More
Not all writers write good grammar. That's a fact. It's... Read More
I'm a writing fool! 2 book proposals, 1 user's guide,... Read More
Creative Writing Tips ?It should.A theme is a one-line explanation... Read More
Often, time is an enemy of writers. Sales seem slow... Read More
If you are a serious writer who wants to publish... Read More
For any great novelist, defining your cast of intriguing characters... Read More
Before I became a teacher, I was a sports writer.... Read More
If you are looking for copywriter books, you'll want to... Read More
So you want to be a successful author? You want... Read More
A few days ago, I critiqued a chapter for a... Read More
Is your book nearly finished, finished, published, or even in... Read More
11 Secrets from an Experienced InterviewerOne of the unwritten rules... Read More
Let's Discuss Publisher Ethics:If you are an ezine publisher or... Read More
As one of those fabulous Baby Boomers, you now own... Read More
Over the past eight years or so, I have tutored... Read More
Next time you're tempted to use italics for emphasis... STOP!"Why?"... Read More
If you want to be a writer, you must write... Read More
Imagine a three hundred page book was in the author's... Read More
Writing is a personal and introspective process. To share with... Read More
I've noticed a big shift away from traditional horror recently,... Read More
The only way to become a writer is to write.... Read More
Screenwriting is a competitive trade. To distinguish yourself as a... Read More
First, let's tackle the question that is uppermost in many... Read More
For several years before I left teaching to write full... Read More
Creative Writing Tips ?Your theme has to be something you... Read More
The biggest mistake authors make when trying to get free... Read More
There are many ways you can generate ideas you can... Read More
The greatest gift you have to give to yourself and... Read More
Do you want to publish something? An article, a non-fiction... Read More
How to Start Your Story with a BangThe purpose of... Read More
All sales begin with some form of advertising whether it's... Read More
Writing |