Atkins Diet Plan -- Are Low Carb Diets Doomed?

According to Veronica Atkins, the widow of Dr. Robert Atkins, the cause of his death was from falling on a slippery sidewalk with subsequent irreversible brain damage (from a CNN interview, February, 2004). Many critics of the Atkins Diet Plan claim the fall was due to a heart attack. This has not been verified to date.

He was 72 years old.

With all due respect to Veronica Atkins, I would like to assume Dr. Atkins did in fact suffer a fatal heart attack. This is in order to answer the following questions...

  • Is it right to use his death as evidence against the safety of the Atkins Diet Plan and other low Carb diets?

  • Does the recent bankruptcy of the Atkins Corporation provide evidence for the ineffectiveness of low Carb diets?

  • Many critics of low Carb diets say yes to both questions, but are they right?

    • The Atkins Diet Plan & Cardiovascular Risk

    Medically speaking, it is incorrect to associate Dr. Atkins' fatal heart attack to the use of his low Carb diet. There are two reasons for coming to this conclusion.

  • The increased risk for cardiovascular events associated with Atkins Diet Plan are not from restricting carbohydrates. Instead, the higher risk of cardiovascular events comes from replacing carbohydrates with foods high in saturated fats.

  • Dr. Atkins died at the age of 72. Beyond the age of 72, the risk for a cardiovascular event is the same for everyone. Granted, he was diagnosed with a cardiomyopathy (diseased heart muscle) when he was 69 and he suffered a heart attack in early 2004.

    However, both events occurred well above the age of 55...the cut off used for men to assign an increased risk for cardiovascular events to their first degree relatives. He was at an age which allows for the exclusion of any significant cardiovascular risk passing to his children.

    • From an epidemiology view point, risk behaviors like smoking or eating a high fat diet are no longer considered as primary contributors in Dr. Atkins' death.

    Yes, eating a high fat diet may have played a role, but this is only speculation. Because Dr. Atkins was 72 at the time of his death, no risk for similar events is passed onto his first degree relatives and the risk for cardiovascular events is the same for everyone at that age.

    With all due respect, he died of old age. To blame the Atkins Diet Plan and low Carb diets in general is medically irresponsible. At 72 years old, there are several factors to consider when faced with a fatal heart attack, including the aging process itself.

    Veronica Atkins was quoted by CNN...

    "My husbands health at the time of his death is a sad and distracting sideshow, taking time away from an intelligent debate of the known science."

    For a more detailed discussion on cardiovascular risk and age, please visit...

    www.medscape.com

    Low Carb Bankruptcy -- Evidence for its Ineffectiveness?

    The only correct way to measure a diet's effectiveness (or lack there of) is to study the evidence provided by clinical trials. Recently, a few good studies have reported on the effectiveness of the Atkins Diet Plan and other low Carb diets.

    In short, low Carb diets, measured at one year, are safe and effective in helping dieters lose weight.

    Like all diet types, the evidence for long term effectiveness (2 to 5 years) is sparse and inconsistent.

    Cardiovascular risk increases for some dieters on low Carb diets, not because of the carbohydrate restriction, but because of the consumption of foods high in fat. Also, sticking with the low Carb diet appears to be tough for most dieters beyond one year.

    And lastly, low Carb diets that promote long stages of measurable ketosis may cause rapid weight loss that is too extreme. This is a great way to guarantee weight regain in the near future.

    Conclusion

    Atkins death, from whatever the cause, can not be associated with his diet because he was 72 years old at the time of his death. Even if Dr. Atkins' death could be associated with his diet, no correlations could be made to similar low Carb diets, too much variation exists between them.

    Bankruptcy does not belong in a scientific discussion of a diet's effectiveness.

    To Healthy Living!

    Michael A. Smith, MD
    Chief Medical Consultant
    Diet Basics Web Site

    Dr. Smith is the Chief Medical Consultant for Diet Basics, a content rich weight loss website dedicated to all dieters. Please visit his site at...

    The Weight Loss Professional

    In The News:

    pen paper and inkwell


    cat break through


    Weight Loss Programs:The 7 Critical Points You Must Check Before You Choose

    Yes, you must be aware of the following 7 points... Read More

    Motivation the Key or the Curse?

    "Life would be perfect if only I was thin." That... Read More

    Are Your Co-Workers Making You Fat? Avoiding Unexpected Treats

    Taming the See Food Eat Food ResponseWhat happens when you're... Read More

    Are You Confused By All The Different Diets? Heres A Quick Diet Comparison

    It would not be surprising to hear your answer is... Read More

    Weight Loss, Exercise, and New Years Resolutions ? Why They Dont Work?

    We have all set them, and we will revisit them... Read More

    Lose Weight - Think You Cant?

    You step on the scale and groan at the number... Read More

    The Truth About Diet Myths

    How do we know what we know? Often, our knowledge... Read More

    Keen To Be Lean? ? Some Metabolic Musings

    Metabolism is the process by which your body changes food... Read More

    The Ultimate Weight Loss Red-Flag Guide

    Weight Loss Red Flag GuideDespite claims to the contrary, there... Read More

    Lose Weight and Get Fit by Getting Fat

    Getting enough of the good fats will help you lose... Read More

    Saint Valentine Never Had it So Good

    There are several theories on the origins of Valentine's Day.... Read More

    Approaches to the Treatment of Obesity and A Free Weight Loss Formula

    The general approach for treatment of obesity is to suggest... Read More

    Choose to Lose - The Simplicity of Weight Loss and Understanding Emotional Eating

    Permanent Weight loss is not about Diet. If you are... Read More

    The Diet Pill They Don?t Want You to Have is Back

    It comes as a surprise to many consumers that the... Read More

    Measuring and Monitoring Your Bodyfat: Improves Overall Health

    With so many diets and fads being offered on the... Read More

    Empowerment and Self-Control - What it Really Takes to get Control of your Weight

    Chant the following each day, several times. They are mantras... Read More

    How to Do the Atkins Diet Right?

    Let me tell you something - if you are doing... Read More

    Focus: A Weight Loss Strategy

    I just finished working my quads on a weight machine.... Read More

    Whats Wrong With Dr. Phils Food Plan?

    I really like Dr. Phil, so I wanted to like... Read More

    5-Step Weight Loss Program for Permanent Weight Loss

    Every Journey Worth Taking Begins with a Single StepHere are... Read More

    Weight Loss: Keeping Your Results Over the Summer

    Having just returned from a week of basking on a... Read More

    Zone Diet Weight Loss Program

    The Zone Diet as a weight loss program has been... Read More

    Holiday Eating: Party Hearty Without Putting on the Pounds!

    The holidays are definitely a special time of year. These... Read More

    8 Proven Weight Loss Tips

    There are a lot of "crash" diets out there that... Read More

    The Magic Formula Works its Wonder Today Part 4

    The people of earlier times depended on the rich resource... Read More

    No Excuse on Getting in Shape

    America is getting more obese every year. Even our children... Read More

    Five Serious Dangers of Low Carbohydrate Diets

    CancerCoronary heart diseaseStrokeOsteoporosisMajor Depression from Brain StarvationHeadlines.WASHINGTON, Jun 22, 2004... Read More

    Coconut Oil Diets

    Have you heard about coconut oil diets yet? People are... Read More

    Weight Loss Support Groups: Lose Weight & Keep It Off With Your Friends At The Phentermine Forum

    We all know it's hard to begin losing weight, no... Read More

    America Health Watch

    America loves fast food. Last year, consumers spent billions of... Read More

    Sale Offers, Ephedra, and Weight Loss... Are You A TARGET?

    Today, Ephedra is an herb of controversy. It contains ephedrine,... Read More

    Calcium - The Key To Quick Weight Loss

    Are you dieting your way to bone loss?Are you aware... Read More

    Help me, Im Addicted to Sugar

    A client wrote, "Help me! I thought I was finally... Read More