What Obesity Debate?

This is a perfect example of how on-line weight loss "experts" can confuse and harm the American consumer...The Obesity Debate?

During a dinner conversation with a friend, the topic of laziness was brought up. From there, we some how got around to the topic of obesity. He said to me, "A great example of how bad laziness can be is obesity."

"Excuse me," I coughed out (almost chocking on the last bite).

"You know, obese people don't do anything. They are fat because they are lazy," my friend said as if from a position of authority. This was going to be a long dinner I could tell.

It turns out, my friend read an article posted on the net that started with a statement similar to my friend's words that almost made me choke. Unfortunately, he didn't remember the author's name but the title was Fitness and Exercise -- I haven't found it...yet.

What blows my mind is how easily people believe what is written on a website by someone calling himself an expert! The real experts need to start making noise!

Laziness does not cause obesity. If that were so, obesity would be the norm and not considered a problem. I recently found a wonderful definition of obesity...it covers all the possibilities in one clear sentence:

The etiology of obesity is complex, determined by the interplay of genetic and environmental factors -Andrea Baessler, from her recent article in Diabetes, Jan, 2005.

There has never been a debate about what causes obesity. We have always known that obesity is multifactorial in etiology. The "real" debate topics are which environmental factors and which genes increase the risk or incidence of obesity. The rest of the article reviews recent work around two genetic links to obesity.

SREB-1 Gene

Delphine Eberle's work (Diabetes, Aug, 2004), with the sterol regulatory element binding protein transcription factor, found that the two isoforms are linked to the "plasma leptin concentrations in American obese families."

His group hypothesized, "...genetic variations of the SREB-1 gene could be associated with obesity and obesity-related metabolic traits such as insulin resistance, type 2 diabetes, and dyslipidemia."

Interestingly, SREB-1 gene polymorphisms were found among obese cohorts when compared to nonobese cohorts. This means they are on to something and possibly not far from marking the SREB-1 gene as a clear link to obesity (1).

Ghrelin Receptor Gene (GHSR)

The importance of ghrelin in the central regulation of feeding has been demonstrated in animals and humans. Ghrelin increases appetite and food intake in normal subjects and patients with decreased appetite, such as those suffering from cancer cachexia. Recent evidence suggests that obesity is associated with an impairment of the entire ghrelin system (2).

Besides its biological function, the ghrelin receptor gene is located in a quantitative trait locus or QTL strongly linked to six phenotypes of obesity (1).

This is a second strong genetic association to obesity. Both groups will soon have conclusive evidence to support their arguments for SREB-1 and GHSR genetic links to obesity.

As far as I can tell, laziness wasn't mentioned once. How many wonderful people avoid treatment because they actually believe it's their own fault?

Educate at all costs.

Healthy Living!
Michael A. Smith, M.D.

Additional Information is available at The Weight Loss Professional

References:

  • Baessler A, Hasinoff J, Fischer M: Genetic linkage and association of the growth hormone secretagogue receptor gene in human obesity. Diabetes, Jan, 2005.


  • Eberle D. SREB-1 gene polymorphisms are associated with obesity and type 2 diabetes in French obese and diabetic cohorts. Diabetes, Aug, 2004.


  • Flegal KM, Carroll MD, Ogden CL, Johnson CL: Prevalence and trends in obesity among US adults, 1999-2000. JAMA 288:1723-1727, 2002

    • Dr. Smith is the primary physician and consultant for the Weight Loss Professional Website. His interests include preventative medicine, the genetic etiology of obesity, and several others too numerous to list.

    Please visit his website at http://www.weight-loss-professional.com and let him know what you think.

    In The News:

    pen paper and inkwell


    cat break through


    What to Eat After Gastric Bypass Surgery

    Many people are under the impression that gastric bypass surgery... Read More

    The Truth About Weight Loss Marketing

    Weight loss, diets and "carbs" are common household topics. There... Read More

    NotOneOunce -- The Run-up To Thanksgiving

    The 8-Week Campaign to Survive the HolidaysEating preparations in the... Read More

    Law of Attraction Resolves Diet Controversy

    Who'd have thought healthy eating could be so controversial? Lunching... Read More

    Weight Loss, Fitness, and a Peace of Mind for Life! The Secret is NOT in the Charts!

    I am Greg Ryan, a high profile fitness expert with... Read More

    Body Dysmorphia: Mind Games After Gastric Bypass Surgery

    Maybe you've heard about body dysmorphia ? it's a mental... Read More

    Hypnosis, Weight Control, and The Thought That Wont Go Away

    You've decided it's time to lose some weight. A lot... Read More

    The College Student?s Guide for EASY WEIGHT LOSS!

    Weight loss is a hot topic among college students today,... Read More

    A Personal Trainers...Holidaze

    Rules of day to day no longer apply as you... Read More

    Fish! It?s What?s For Dinner After Gastric Bypass

    Since gastric bypass weight loss surgery gives us a second... Read More

    Lose Weight and Exercise Now ? Or Face the Music Later!

    My responsibility as a high profile fitness expert lies not... Read More

    What Cows Know About Weight Loss That We Have Forgotten

    I want to talk to you about cows and what... Read More

    Gastric Bypass Causes Hair Loss: Can It Be Avoided?

    Surprisingly, hair loss is one of the reasons female pre-operative... Read More

    Obesity, Whats The Big Deal

    Nowadays, so much of the public is obese (fat) that... Read More

    5 Tips to Keep Your Mental Health in Shape as You Diet

    Losing weight and going on a diet can be quite... Read More

    Close Kept Secrets to Weight Loss Lesson #14

    You know what is so amazing? We get to keep... Read More

    How to Lose Weight While Gardening

    Have you ever dreaded the idea of pulling weeds, planting... Read More

    An Incredible New Weight Loss Product ? Your Brain!

    I would like to introduce you to an incredible new... Read More

    A Soda a Day: How is it Affecting Your Weight?

    Many people limit themselves to one soda a day especially... Read More

    Exercise, Diet and Weight Loss ? When Do Your Desires Turn into Lifestyle Habits?

    Just one more day I can do this, I told... Read More

    Lose Fat and Retain Muscle By Getting In Touch With Hunger

    "Unless that apple tastes like the best apple you've ever... Read More

    On A Diet? Ensure You Get Enough Nutritional Supplements For Your Good Health

    There is never any absolute certainty about what the nutritional... Read More

    Hydrate to Lose Weight: The Real Skinny On Water Retention and Sodium

    If you've been scouring the news, devouring as much information... Read More

    When Emotional Eating Becomes an Eating Disorder

    More and more people are starting to recognize that they... Read More

    Brinks Unified Theory of Nutrition For Weight Loss and Muscle Gain

    When people hear the term Unified Theory, some times called... Read More

    Weight Loss Issues - Can You Be Cellulite Free?

    One thing I really must say at the outset of... Read More

    Low Carbohydrate Diet Revolution -- A History

    Most people think of the Atkins diet when they hear... Read More

    Are Weight Loss Supplements Right For You?

    The debate about whether supplements for weight loss are healthy... Read More

    Walking, Water, and Weight Watchers: The 3 W?s for Weight Loss

    I have been seriously working on losing weight for about... Read More

    Questioning Cardio for Weight Loss?

    Q: I've heard you mention that you don't need tons... Read More

    Understand the Science of Obesity And Youre On Your Way To Conquer It

    Many people think obesity means that a person is overweight,... Read More

    Obesity as an Issue Today and the Half Ton Man

    Following recent reports of a South Dakota man weighing half... Read More

    Criteria to Consider When Selecting a Bariatric Surgery Center

    According to the American College of Surgeons, most severely obese... Read More