Ethical Link Exchange, You be the Judge

Webmasters understand that quality and relevant inbound links can increase site visibility; your search engine rating; and with any luck increase your traffic and revenue.

While working to locate relevant links for our site, we discovered a disturbing practice apparently being used to increase link popularity and search engine ranking. The following are the sorted details of our journey and discovery.

1) Most webmasters understand the hunt for quality relevant sites is, like most things of value in life, a time consuming and difficult task. Being limited on time, we first tried to hire a leading SEO expert to locate relevant links. When the SEO expert did not return emails, we tried a few link exchange sites. While a few good quality links were unearthed, the link exchange sites simply did not offer a large quantity of good relevant sites. After all, our competitors had hundreds of thousands of inbound links and we had less than 900. While tempting, we skipped over the advertisements for traffic as our desire was for prospective customers not traffic.

2) We finally decided on the DIY approach. First step, check current reciprocal links page to insure all was well. A few sites no longer linked to us, so our webmaster links page required a few updates.

3) Next we chose to use Link Popularity Check to locate links that our competitors have, that we perhaps missed. The first thing we noticed was hundreds of inbound links a competitor had, all coming from a few specific sites. Upon visiting the sites, we noticed that one was a "directory" and several others were normal sites that contained very little content. In short, the directory and other sites were nothing a competent webmaster could not create in a day or two.

4) We found it odd the inbound sites all have the same visual look, color scheme, and navigation. Our competitor's site was also listed in the "Related Resources" area on each and every page. The light bulb suddenly switched on! The inbound sites appeared to have been created for the sole purpose of increasing link popularity and therefore the competitor's search engine ranking!

5) Ping the four sites to locate the IP addresses. Four different addresses, not in consecutive order. Perhaps we were mistaken.

6) A few mouse clicks to see who owned the domain names of the four sites. All the sites are owned by the same company, are housed at the same ISP, and have the same email address listed for the administrative and technical contact names.

7) A few mouse clicks at Alexa.com to review traffic patterns show the sites have very little traffic, yet all have a PageRank score of 6 or higher. Site traffic is increasing for each.

Nope, it does not appear we were mistaken. It appears a competitor actually created web sites for the sole purchase of increasing his/her link popularity and search engine ranking for their primary business site. To recreate such a process:

  • Register a domain name that is tied to your primary sites keyword list. For example, if your primary site sells widgets and has a domain name of Widgets.com, something like "Widget- Directory.com" would be ideal;

  • Setup a new hosting account with your ISP, using a different IP address, for Widget-Directory.com;

  • Create a few pages that use the keyword list from Widgets.com, then setup a link system that invites webmasters to exchange links. Remember, no need to get carried away with content as the purpose of Widget-Directory is really keyword tie-in and link exchanges;

  • Now, code every page of Widget-Directory with a link back to Widget.com;

  • Sit back and watch. As webmasters enter their sites and subcategories into Widget-Directory, the results will increase the link quantity and apparently your search engine ranking of Widget-Directory AND Widgets.com.

We were curious to see if this was an isolated incident or a rampant practice. While not rampant, it did not take us long to find others companies utilizing this technique. Is this ethical? I am sure some would argue this is a savvy internet marketing practice, while others will view the practice as repulsive. Ethical or not, this technique is simple, cost effective, and apparently will increase your search engine ranking. One thing is clear, I will never look at directory sites or link exchange pages the same.

Hopefully, the search engine will adjust their algorithms and nullify this practice. In the interim, for those that take a negative PR and/or link exchange hit, remember that honesty builds longevity and lasting relationships. Remember the SEO expert we previously tried to hire? We went back and checked his site, and yes he utilizes the same technique. Odd thing however, his sites no longer enjoys top ratings on the major search engines. Perhaps, the search engines are starting to figure this one out.

Lew Newlin is CTO of Information Solutions, Inc. that operates SiteRecon that specializes in email monitoring and web site monitoring for businesses.

In The News:


pen paper and inkwell


cat break through


To Create a Perpetual Traffic Generator

What runs through your mind when you hear that ezine... Read More

Driving Qualified Traffic Using Directories

Some education is essential to enlighten you about this form... Read More

7 Great Tips on Driving Targeted Traffic to Your Website

We all need traffic. It's the life-blood of an online... Read More

Marketing Your Website Inexpensively

There are a number ways you can go about marketing... Read More

How To Generate Targeted Traffic...and Cash In On It.

We all know that generating traffic to your site is... Read More

The Old But Reliable Ways of Attracting Free Online Traffics

Every home business owner should know that your WEBSITE TRAFFICS... Read More

If you need More Targeted Visitors to Your Site this Will get the Free Traffic Flowing

If you don't know by now one the best ways... Read More

Vote for Your Own Website - Nobody Will Mind

OK boys and girls. Today we're having a pop quiz.I... Read More

Viral Marketing Technique Creates a Chain Reaction with One-Time Action!

Suddenly your site's traffic multiplies. You get "Money Waiting" emails... Read More

Zero Cost Quality Traffic For Your Home Business

Do you know that you can promote your home business... Read More

Why Traffic Touts and List Pushers Are Bad For Your Business

In this Article we look at the second competitive advantage... Read More

Web Site Marketing: 10 Volcanic Ways To Erupt Your Website Sales

Do you want to pump up sales at your website?If... Read More

Internet Promotion: 10 Uncommon Freebies That Can Increase Your Traffic And Sales

It is an open internet promotion secret that the more... Read More

Web Site Monitoring Is A Global Necessity

Bill Huang sits down at his computer. As he connects... Read More

Step Into My Parlour? Easy Ways To Entice The Right People To Your Website

Though traditional marketing methods cannot be ignored, having a website... Read More

10 Highly Effective Ways to Increase Traffic to Your Website

There are many ways to promote your website for free... Read More

Good Traffic is Targeted Traffic

Targeted traffic: the demographicAssuming your business is motorcycles, my first... Read More

Free Traffic Course - Day 7

When you work with web site traffic, you must have... Read More

Are Links From Unrelated Sites Really That Bad?

When I started GetQuotes-IT.com in 2003, I knew... Read More

No Cost Ways To Increase Your Web Site Traffic Promotion

Web site traffic promotion is crucial in today's Internet world.... Read More

8 Steps for Getting Free Traffic to Your Website

Want to Make Free Money on the Internet?One of the... Read More

Utilize Those Traffic Exchanges.

I`ve had people come to me and say "Traffic Exchanges... Read More

Common Sense Link Exchange

Creating a simple links page to exchange links for the... Read More

A Simple Guide to Analyzing All Those Web Traffic Ideas - Part 2

Just to recap - Part 1 of this article outlined... Read More

Rethinking Linking - Link Exchange Back to Basics

In the old days of the internet, links were the... Read More

Ultimately Increase Your Traffic & Profits

By doing one thing solve other people's problems.That's it this... Read More

Get More Customers ? With Less Work!

A lot of website owners work tirelessly at increasing their... Read More

Simple Steps to Increase Traffic to Your Website

Every website owner wants their website to be popular; some... Read More

Build Your Inbound Site Links Without Requesting Reciprocal Links

A funny thing happened to me three months ago. I... Read More

Power Packed Linking Strategies - Part One

This is the first in a series of three articles... Read More

TARGET PRACTICE - Generating The Website Traffic That Matters

But a mere increase in the volume of website traffic... Read More

Guidelines To A Successful Link Exchange Program

Webmasters look for ways to get a higher ranking with... Read More

The FREE Web Traffic Explosion Method

Dear Friend,Many people like to listen to all the graphic... Read More