What is the Filibuster-Breaking Nuclear Option?

What is the so-called "nuclear option" that Senator Bill Frist may deploy soon in a precedent-setting attempt to break a potential filibuster? It sounds ominous, but what is it all about, really?

President Bush has the opportunity to nominate and fill numerous federal judicial positions this year. Eventually he will have the opportunity to nominate one or more Supreme Court jusices as well. However,this issue isn't about the potential Supreme Court nominations yet, but ultimately it will be.

The Democrats in the Senate plan to use the filibuster to prevent the Senate from voting on the federal judicial nominees that the Democrats see as objectionable. A simple majority of 51 Senators is needed to confirm the nominees. However, once a filibuster has begun, 60 votes are then required to invoke cloture, ending the filibuster, and forcing a vote. There are 55 Republicans in the current Senate, enough votes to confirm President Bush's federal judicial nominees, but not enough to break a nomination-ending filibuster without bipartisan cooperation.

The Republicans contend that requiring 60 votes to effectively confirm a nomination is unconstitutional. The Constitution is imprecise on this point. The Constitution only asks the Congress to "advise and consent" regarding judicial nominees, which implies that only a simple majority vote is needed. The Democrats contend that the filibuster is not unconstitutional and has been used often in the past by the minority party, both Republican and Democratic, and that rules governing its usage should be left intact.

Republican Senator Bill Frist has proposed the "nuclear option," which would set a precedent and effectively change the rules. Currently, Senate Rule XXII stipulates that invoking cloture requires a supporting vote of 60%, and it further stipulates that to change the rule requires a supporting vote of 67%.

Here's one possible scenario about how Senator Frist might trigger the "nuclear option."

1. A controversial judicial nomination goes to the Senate floor for consideration.
2. Senate Democrats begin a filibuster to prevent a confirmation vote.
3. Senator Frist raises a Point of Order. He contends that further debate would be dilatory and that a vote must be taken within a specific period of time.
4. Vice President Cheney, the presiding officer, sustains the Point of Order.
5. A Democratic Senator appeals the ruling.
6. A Republican Senator moves to table the appeal, which would effectively eliminate the appeal.
7. The Senate votes on the motion to table the appeal. This is a procedural issue and cannot be filibustered. Only 51 votes are needed to pass the motion to table the appeal.
8. If only 50 Senators vote to table the appeal, Vice President Cheney can cast the tie-breaking vote. 51 votes would sustain the ruling, thus requiring the filibuster to end within a specified time frame.

This is considered a "nuclear option" because it circumvents Senate Rule XXII which governs cloture. It also would cause further division among Republicans and Democrats, making bipartisan cooperation in the future more difficult. The option would also be a tactic that would be used against the Republicans in the future when they are the minority party and a Democratic President nominates federal judges.

Garry Gamber is a public school teacher. He writes articles about politics, real estate, health and nutrition, and internet dating services. He is a founding member of http://www.GoodPoliticsRadio.com and the owner of http://www.TheDatingAdvisor.com.

---

The Economics of Cloning Armies or Super Families

Let's put the religious part of the debate for a... Read More

Smelter Closures In America Hurt Our Industrial Output

The United States is losing its industrial capacity quite rapidly.... Read More

Will Cloning of Super Families Lead to Slavery

If slavery has not worked well, then cloning if it... Read More

Economic Illiteracy Can Be Very Costly!

I'VE ALWAYS ARGUED THAT ECONOMIC ILLITERACY IS VERY COSTLY.This is... Read More

The Halakah and Neo Cons

These leaders like the Rothschilds who backed Crowley's Hermetic Order... Read More

More Devastating Than a Nuclear Bomb

Despite their signature on the Biological Weapons Convention of 1975,... Read More

Is America Bankrupt?

The US Dollar has been falling continuously in last year.... Read More

Social Security Rant

As the Baby Boomer Generation continue to get older, one... Read More

I am Not an African American

I am not an African-American. Don't call me an African... Read More

The European Bank for the Retardation of Development

In typical bureaucratese, the pensive EBRD analyst ventures with the... Read More

Protecting Children From Porn

There's a new Michigan state register in the works... Read More

Question Authority

Policemen in many US cities are taking their new authority... Read More

Enlightenment Experiments

Pierre Dupont de Nemours:After arranging the Armistice that ended or... Read More

All Extremists Go To Heaven... Dont They

Heaven, Hell, or some sort of Purgatory.I cannot seem to... Read More

Whose Afraid of the Government; Whose the Government Afraid of?

We need a government that can be as responsive to... Read More

Ground Gas Canisters for Land Mines

Land Mines have been one of the most evil left... Read More

Media Advertising: New Alcohol Advertising Codes - 1 October 2005

Businesses advertising alcohol either in TV or non-broadcast format need... Read More

Pierre Dupont de Nemours

After arranging the Armistice that ended or settled outstanding issues... Read More

Freedom on the Internet

Throughout all recorded history on our lovely little planet, Earth's... Read More

The Distributive Justice of the Market

(1) Each person is to have an equal right to... Read More

Using More Trees to Reduce Atmospheric CO2

As global warming continues to escalate the concerns of today's... Read More

The Fed and Other Garbage

"The Jesuit priest John H. Surratt, proven to be the... Read More

Free Trade, Outsourcing, Protectionism and Reality Check

Recently on C-SPAN, there were two gentlemen debating free trade... Read More

May Day, May Day

Down The Bush and BlairBy now everyone, except us, is... Read More

Suicide Prevention in Prisons

Prison guards and corrections professionals are hard at work insuring... Read More

NASA Budget Space Shuttle Thoughts

Regarding the issues with the Space Shuttle and the in... Read More

Governments Worst Agency

Everyone knows the United States Government often falls down in... Read More

Let me throw out a random thought on Homeland Security Leadership Structure

Streamlining Homeland Security with a Free market flair? An idea... Read More

Globalism and a Conspiracy

The globalist's are the new breed, the new generation if... Read More

Profiling Eco-terrorists

The FBI recently before Congress stated that Eco-Terrorism was on... Read More

The Morality of Using Stem Cells

One third of all fertilized eggs spontaneously abort and are... Read More

Colts? Stadium Short on Horse Sense

The predominant discussion in the Indianapolis media over the proposed... Read More

Carl Rove and the Case of Sour Grapes

The Carl Rove issue is definitely interesting and distracting. The... Read More