Insurance Credit Scoring: An Ethical Issue

The issue at hand is the use of a consumer's credit score as an underwriting tool for auto insurance rates. What is a credit score or FICO score? A FICO score is a credit score developed by Fair Isaac & Co. Credit scoring is a method of determining the likelihood that credit users will pay their bills. Fair, Isaac began its work with credit scoring in the late 1950s and, since then, scoring has become widely accepted by lenders as a reliable means of credit evaluation. A credit score attempts to condense a borrower's credit history into a single number. Fair, Isaac & Co. and the credit bureaus do not reveal how these scores are computed. The Federal Trade Commission has ruled this to be acceptable.

Isn't it interesting that the score most important in our financial lives, our consumer credit score does not even contain full disclosure? As stated above the Federal Trade Commission has ruled that it is ok for Fair Isaac & Co not to disclose the algorithms used in this process, but what about consumer rights.

While it is important to understand what a FICO score is, it is not the main issue of this paper, insurance rates are. So where is the connection? All the public knows is that Fair Isaac tells us there is a high correlation between people with bad credit and high risk drivers. This notion is insane and from what I can see from this black box approach, there is no real causation between the two.

This type of reasoning is similar to convicting a person of something before they have even committed a crime. For instance, let's say I do a study and that study shows there is a high correlation between criminals and people with bad credit. Is this to say that just because you have bad credit you are more likely to commit a crime and therefore you should be profiled or perhaps locked up because you are a risk to society?

This system is discriminating against minorities, disabled and in my case college students among others. Fair Isaac & Co claims that they cannot show the sophisticated algorithms they use to calculate these correlations and scores because they fear that they would be giving up valuable proprietary information that was very costly to develop and maintain. What about the cost to consumer's who may be paying higher rates or in worse cases even denied insurance based on these practices.

The Equal Credit Opportunity Act forbids creditors from considering race, sex, marital status, national origin, and religion, but if we don't even know how these companies are calculating these scores, how in the world could we possibly know whether or not they are discriminating. This smoke and mirror approach is what many government agencies do to subtly discriminate and extort money from the American.

What about extortion? As I reflect on this topic extortion comes to mind. Webster defines extortion as to "obtain by force or compulsion." By using such unfounded tactics consumers are forced into paying the higher rates. First of all, 90% of all insurance companies use this procedure; secondly in the interest of society legislation requires all Americans with cars to have car insurance. Living in a country where it is virtually impossible to live without a car doesn't this present some force to pay the rates? Also, lets say you cannot afford to buy a car with cash, in which case you could obtain liability insurance alone and save quite a lot of money; but instead you take out a loan, the bank will require you to obtain full coverage auto insurance to cover them until you pay off the loan. While this case may not represent an extreme case of extortion it does give reason to ponder the connection.

Insurance companies tout themselves as representing peace of mind, protection and security, but at what cost. Over the past 10 years, I have spent roughly 20,000 dollars in car insurance, what have I claimed? Easily less than half and I totaled a car. Is insurance just a form of legalized gambling protected by government? The McCarran-Ferguson Act of 1944 exempts the insurance industry from antitrust laws, so here we are again without a choice; collusion is the rule not competition. Where are the ethics of lawmakers? Many states are screaming about this controversial issue and some states such as California have had some success, but with protection from top government what can consumers do?

I have personally written the Governor of Pennsylvania about the subject, one of my main questions was;

"I am a concerned citizen. Recently I noticed my car insurance rates increasing at a substantial rate. I investigated the situation only to find out that my credit rating was making the difference, not my driving record."

The response I received from the Department of Insurance follows:

This letter is in reponse to your complaint filed with the Pennsylvania Insurance Dpartment through Governor Edward G. Rendell's correspondence office regarding the use of credit as an underwriting tool for automobile insurance in Pennsylvania.

I have read through your concerns and it appears that you are questioning the underwriting of automobile insurance. Specifically, the use of credit in determining eligibility. Many different factors go into the underwriting of an insurance policy, such as type of vehicle, drivers, location, etc. and most recently credit history. Pennsylvania law does not prohibit an insurance company fromusing credit as an underwriting tool so long as it is done within the first 60 days of writing a policy. Under the law, an insurance company is granted a 60 day window from the inception of a policy to determine whether or not the policy fits into the company's guidelines.

In your letter, you stated credit scoring in part of the rating structure and presumable must be approved by the Insurance Department. Actually, credit scoring is part of a company's underwriting guidelines and the Dapartment only regulates underwriting guideline to the extent they are not discriminatory.

Also, Federal law under the Fair Credit Reporting Act allows credit information to be used for underwriting financial and insurance transactions.

Sincerely yours,

Debra L. Roadcap

Consumer Service Investigator

The response I received is hardly what I would call an answer, of course Federal Law preempts state law and the Fair Credit Reporting Act allows for use of such information, but the real question is why? An answer to this question has still not been received. I believe this is a highly unethical practice in which insurance companies are being given free rule to take advantage of low-income families, single mothers, disabled, minorities and others. If the government wants to do the right thing they should judge consumers on what they have done individually, not what scientist's hypothesis they might do based on the history of others.

About The Author

My name is Richard D. Schrader, I advocate consumer education on many topics and help consult American consumers with excessive credit card debt. You can visit my website at www.debtjustice.net

webmaster@debtjustice.net

---

Compare Car Insurance Companies Before You Commit

If you want to save money on your car insurance,... Read More

Why Does Health Insurance Cost So Much?

Why does health insurance cost so much? Year after year,... Read More

Mortgage Life Insurance

Owning a home is a dream for most of us,... Read More

Online Health Insurance Quotes - Finding The Cheapest Rates Possible

Shopping for health insurance can be very discouraging when you... Read More

Risk Retention Groups RRG

In response to a hard insurance market in the mid... Read More

Insurance Providers Weather the Storm While Consumers Flounder

We have just had the first year's anniversary of the... Read More

Auto Insurance for Young Drivers

The biggest worry of most parents today is their children... Read More

Guide to Car Insurance

Here is a useful guide to car insurance. Buying car... Read More

Why Dont Insurance Companies Reward Us for Being Healthy?

Insurance is always a gamble, a bet actually.You are betting... Read More

Car Insurance Rates ? Can You Lower Them?

Car insurance rates are prohibitive nowadays. Many families really struggle... Read More

Insurance for Car Wash Fundraisers

Non-profit groups in this day and age need to watch... Read More

Life Insurance: Why Theres No Need to be a Desperate Housewife

Life insurance looks set to make a comeback in the... Read More

Affordable Health Insurance - Health Insurance For The Self Employed

One of the things that is important to consider when... Read More

Insurance in Northern Ireland: Historic Difficulties

No doubt most readers will have heard of the Northern... Read More

Filing Homeowners Insurance Claim Forms: What Steps to Take

Filing a homeowners insurance claim can be done with ease... Read More

Young Driver Car Insurance

It has become increasingly difficult to get young driver car... Read More

Health Insurance Plans and their Differences

Health insurance plans have changed dramatically over the past ten... Read More

The Importance of Travel Insurance

You've finally saved enough to go on that dream vacation... Read More

Know Your Own Worth: A Practical Insight Into Covering Up

Almost anything can be insured these days: breasts, legs, your... Read More

What Is Permanent Life Insurance?

Unlike term life insurance, permanent insurance policies such as universal... Read More

Life Insurance Providing Little Protection from Terrorism

Recent statements by the City of London Police Commissioner James... Read More

Need A Car Insurance Comparison? Dont Have Time?

If you decide not to do a car insurance comparison... Read More

How Many Homeowner Insurance Quotes Do I Need To Save Money?

Homeowner insurance quotes can vary in the amount they cost... Read More

Apply Online for Temporary Health Insurance

There are times when you'll find yourself temporarily without health... Read More

Discount Auto Insurance

Whether you are looking for car insurance in Canada, the... Read More

Senior Health Care Insurance

Health Insurance For Seniors On The NetWhen a good friend... Read More

Self Employed Health Insurance - Tips For Getting Cheap Health Insurance When Youre Self Employed

If you're self-employed and facing high health insurance bills, there... Read More

How To Get Cheap Whole Life Insurance Quotes

Whole life insurance quotes the most expensive kind of policies... Read More

How To Best Handle Health Insurance Plan Changes

Many economists have suggested and recent economic data indicates that... Read More

Car Insurance Discounts

Trying to save money wherever you can is important to... Read More

Finding Life Insurance Quotes For Adult Children

Shopping for life insurance quotes for adult children isn't any... Read More

Are You Sure That Heirloom Oriental Rug From Your Aunt Hilda Is Really Insured?

Gone are the days of the cinder block and wood... Read More

Flat Insurance in the UK

What are the factors involved in flat insurance? Do I... Read More