I get a lot of "reader comments" on the issues I choose to write about. This is a good thing for my editors since this means more readers and more readers mean more advertising revenue. It is good for me too in the sense that I do get some of the greatest writing topics from readers who write me. It can also be a bad thing?sometimes a very bad thing.
What I enjoy are those readers' comments in which readers will take the time to attempt to offer me counter-arguments to the particular position I take in the op-ed pieces I write. What I mean is that there are some readers who realize that the process of clear and linear thinking is not an easy task. It takes work-hard work. One is not always successful-especially your humble columnist.
And, when a reader takes the time to carefully craft and linearly constructed counter-argument, I appreciate it to no end. I appreciate the effort. I enjoy the challenge.
However, most readers' responses I get are NOT carefully crafted, well-constructed counter-arguments. Without fear of contradiction, the vast majority of readers' responses I get are not just poorly constructed but are not counter-arguments at all. Let me give you an example. Here is someone who was attempting, and I credit her for the attempt, to challenge some pieces I wrote on the illegal alien issue:
"And by the way, everything - the numbers, and the data I stated here - I can prove to you if you want me to. It is all true."
This person believed that if she backed the dump truck up, pulled the lever, and dumped a deluge of "stats and facts" that this would constitute "proof" for her Minuteman Project position. She apparently believed that the "preponderance" of "facts" she could provide me constituted "proof" that she was right and I was wrong.
Let me say that I did appreciate this person's attempt. Never once did she resort to the usual fare I encounter: threats to my life, wild profanity, ad hominem, asking what rock I crawled out from under, etc? She tried.
The problem with her reasoning, and which vexes me that Americans do not seem to be able to engage in critical thinking to see this, is that she really sincerely believed her own self-proclamation, "It's all true".
A proclamation of something being true does not constitute proof of a claim. This person is assuming that her evidence is so overwhelming that only a nimrod, a ding-dong could doubt the claims she is supporting with "the data". However, unless this person's "data" can be shown to be the result of the "test of experimentation" then it would be mere speculation and thus the reader would be committing the fallacy of "Selective Use of Evidence".
The issue I think the Minuteman folks seems to miss completely is that when they attend their conferences where their gurus stand before them to rally the forces how do they know whether they are being fed correctly obtained data? How do they know when they are being told the truth and not rehashed rhetoric that is committing the "selective use of statistics" error in critical thinking?
This is a hard question and it is a hard thing to solve.
How do we know that we are using proper and honest statistics in the point we are trying to prove or in the axe we are trying grind? My Minuteman Project readers often miss this point entirely in that they kept sending me e-mail after e-mail with attachments, texts, and entire PDF e-books from so-called experts.
I couldn't possibly read them all!
Those I did read were mainly the rehashing of the same quoted truckload of unproven claims. And they were all some form or another of a work by an "expert" with more degrees behind their names than the weather.
What was lacking in the stats sent to me was the "test of experimentation". And when there were studies quoted there was a total absence of "peer review". In other words, no one replicated (or was able to replicate) the studies.
"The secret language of statistics, so appealing in a fact-minded culture, is employed to sensationalize, inflate, confuse, and oversimplify," warns Huff.[1]
Frankly, I do not believe my Minuteman Project readers get that point at all. Nor do I believe that my Minuteman Project readers understand that because someone is an M.D. or a Ph.D. that they are immune to biases and even dishonesty. Even so-called experts can and do have ulterior motives in reporting "studies" in an attempt to support their biases.
The example I reported is that the Minuteman and their kind will tell you in no uncertain terms that all of America is on the verge of being wiped out of existence by tuberculosis. Yet, when I contacted the CDC, they were not of that opinion.
The Minuteman will use quotes from degreed individuals but who never cite the studies from which they originated nor the "peer reviewed" studies and subsequent results. This is so vital that I cannot risk overstating it:
Honest scientists INSIST upon repeatable experiments! This means that properly conducted experiments have to be able to have their steps repeated by objective third-party scientists-who have no axe to grind--who will come up with the same results in order to establish REAL facts and not just speculations!
You cannot have the PROPER use of statistics if you do not have PROPERLY OBTAINED statistics to quote. Proper stats are the direct result of the properly constructed TEST OF EXPERIMENTATION!
I honestly do not believe that the Minuteman and all their kind get that! Maybe they never will. If they are committing themselves to the Proper Use of Evidence then they should be able to show how that evidence was obtained! They should be able to show, from start to finish, the test constructed to obtain the data, the replication studies, what the result could or could not mean, etc?
To date I have seen nothing of the kind!
[1] America's Anti-Mexican Xenophobia, by Doug Bower
Freelance writer, Syndicated Columnist, and book author, Doug Bower, has written a compelling new book titled, AMERICA'S ANTI-MEXICAN XENOPHOBIA. Have you wondered if the Minuteman Project is really on the "up and up"? Have you wondered if they represent all that is good and right with America-paragons of patriotic virtue? Doug Bower may have the answers you've been looking for. FREE CHAPTER: http://www.lulu.com/content/140958
![]() |
|
![]() |
|
![]() |
|
![]() |
Deal Breakers. Everyone's got them. You know: the instant turn-offs... Read More
Just recently, I felt ready to experience change in a... Read More
Three years ago, I met my boyfriend Andy through the... Read More
I don't know if the craze of SMS has caught... Read More
1) Give yourself time to get back into the groove... Read More
Jody's quest in finding a suitable partner for marriage seemed... Read More
Did you know that Match.com has around twelve million members,... Read More
Did you know that Online Dating is the top moneymaker... Read More
Oh, no! Christmas, Hanukah, and New Year's Eve are coming,... Read More
Has a similar scenario like this one ever happened to... Read More
Did you catch the dating mistakes made during episode one... Read More
Back in the days when I was a teenager, I... Read More
So, you've decided to join a dating website. You're hoping... Read More
The next most likely place to meet your match is... Read More
It sounds like something out of a fairy tale. She's... Read More
It's one of the supreme tragedies in life. When there's... Read More
How often do girls on the street smile to you,... Read More
What do you talk about on a date? Is it... Read More
So, you're convinced that you have zero opportunities to meet... Read More
You went out with the guy. You both had a... Read More
Standing at the magazine rack thumbing through Cosmo, she has... Read More
Harsh words, hurting comments, tears and flying household objects -... Read More
Kiki sat on the park bench, staring ruefully at the... Read More
If you're worried and upset about your physical flaws, which... Read More
I let that friend talk me into browsing some pictures... Read More
If you are single and you want men to desire... Read More
A few months ago I became single again after a... Read More
Valentine's Day was initially an outgrowth of an ancient Roman... Read More
We've all been there. We've fallen in love with somebody... Read More
Honour and respect are two of the most important elements... Read More
As a result of dating for decades and chatting with... Read More
Now you all know I have become a bit cynical... Read More
Romantic relationships happen because of the hopes and dreams a... Read More
The fact is, most people think they handle objections with... Read More
Very few singles have ever gone through life without having... Read More
Just about every dating site-even those with minimal profiles-have space... Read More
"I'll call you this week". "Yes, I'd love to see... Read More
Hello Lucia,I regularly compliment women and tell them that I... Read More
Are you a lonely man?When was the last time you... Read More
Sweet flowers alone can say what passion fears revealing Thomas... Read More
Finally, after a year of mending a broken heart, you... Read More
In order to attract the man of your dreams, it... Read More
Generally the most important step when dating someone is the... Read More
The majority of theories on how to pick up girls... Read More
Many of my clients that I coach are single and... Read More
Ever noticed that when dating, no one really wants to... Read More
We've all been there. You have been meeting her accidentally... Read More
Dating during the holiday season can be a special treat.... Read More
Q. My boyfriend failed a dating quiz. Should I dump... Read More
Dear Relationship Coach-"We met online and seemed to hit it... Read More
Are you writing to someone who is romancing you off... Read More
What do you talk about on a date? Is it... Read More
Are you dating or in a serious relationship? Did you... Read More
Surely you remember that famous line from American Pie, when... Read More
How often do girls on the street smile to you,... Read More
Honour and respect are two of the most important elements... Read More
First dates can be pretty daunting experiences, but they can... Read More
Looking To Meet Women? Craving Female Company?Well, you've come to... Read More
You should show a tolerant and open-minded attitude towards many... Read More
To have a successful conversation with any woman you must... Read More
Online dating service! Is it right for you? That would... Read More
There's something sexy about a powerful, take-charge woman who knows... Read More
There are so many dating sites on the net these... Read More
More American women over 45 are single, than ever before.... Read More
Where are all the good men/women? You go to parties,... Read More
Imagine the joy of finding the love of your life,... Read More
Dating |